Monday, October 16, 2006

Ego

Broadly cloassified, there are 2 types of egos. Ayn Rand, in her 2 books has described 2 such "egoist" personalities.

Howard Roark in "The Fountainhead":
The book's title is a reference to Ayn Rand's statement that "man's ego is the fountainhead of human progress". In the book, Howard Roark is an architect who prefers to struggle in obscurity rather than compromise his artistic and personal vision by pandering to the prevailing taste in building design. Howard Roark lives for himself and his own creativity, indifferent to the opinions of others. Thus, the character depicts ego which built in the positive direction. Here, Ayn Rand conveys that - the ego is supreme, and individualism and selfishness are virtues to be treasured.

James Taggart in "Atlas Shrugged":
In contrast to Howard Roark, James Taggart is not the hero in this this book, nor does he have any individualism. He has no ideas of his own. He is the President of Taggart Transcontinental - a leading railroad company. He is an expert influence peddler who is incapable of making decisions on his own. And he relies on his sister Dagny Taggart to actually run the railroad, but nonetheless opposes her in almost every endeavor. With his character, his egoist attitude comes to the front. He is incapable, but not willing to accept it. His remarks to Dagny, who saves him from all his incorrect decisions are really idiotic. Had James been clever but incapable, he would have let Dagny do all the work for him without opposing her; and things would have been better for himself. He is a person who would ruin himself, to save his ego.

There are many people like James Taggart around us. But to be Howard Roark, it very difficult!

8 comments:

Anonymous said...

and the most difficult question is to know what kind of ego you exactly have: roark-type or taggart-type.

worse, you have to judge it yourself.

teja2001 said...

Nicely summarized.. i love fountainhead as much as i hated atlas shrugged... the ego in fountain head is what we must aspire for... u did say this right !!!

trendwhizo said...

humein kya malum....aap bhi ayn rand ke fan hai !

Mukta A said...

@omkar: yes very rightly said!! and thats what causes all the problems! :)

@teja2006:
we cant aspire to have an ego of some manner. we can aspire to be as good as roark, and we can also try to be original, be confident with your decisions/actions. then the outcome of this behaviour will be termed by the world as "ego": and as omkar said, its difficult for yourself to understand your ego-type... the world will never take any type of ego in a positive way!!

@manik:
i have read fountainhead. am still reading atlas shrugged! :)

Mukta A said...

@omkar: yes very rightly said!! and thats what causes all the problems! :)

@teja2006:
we cant aspire to have an ego of some manner. we can aspire to be as good as roark, and we can also try to be original, be confident with your decisions/actions. then the outcome of this behaviour will be termed by the world as "ego": and as omkar said, its difficult for yourself to understand your ego-type... the world will never take any type of ego in a positive way!!

@manik:
i have read fountainhead. am still reading atlas shrugged! :)

Yagya Datt Sharma said...

nice posts..i like to read inspirational stuff..after readin this ..i think i must read fountainhead :-)

Anonymous said...

I don't think that James Taggart is the protaganist in Atlas Shrugged.

There are a set of people who are potrayed as Atlas like, which include Dagny Taggart, Hank Rearden,Francisco D'Anconia and John Galt.

the ego, which is primary in Atlas shrugged is the one of these people, who actually run the show, but are not given the due credit. All hell breaks loose when these modern Atlases go on a strike.

Mukta A said...

yes you are absolutely rite that the book does not focus on the "ego" aspect at all.

it is my perspective to consider the character of james taggart & think why he is so. as mentioned, he is not the main part of the entire novel. but i believe, if you consider his character, it does show his egoist attitude, when dealing with people.

my point here is: you need not be a mastermind to possess some ego. if someone who isnt capable but develops an ego... now thats whats bad. there are so many people around.

if you are at fault, you do not accept it. why? bcoz its ur ego...

the motive of this article to compare this type of ego, with the "type" of ego that is projected in "the fountainhead"...